May 27, 2008 Ironwood Township
The impasse between the Ironwood Library Board and the Ironwood
Township Board of Supervisors is over. Thanks to level headed
and sensible members of each side, the contract was approved 4-2
at last week's Library Board Meeting and was ratified tonight by
a 6-1 vote at Township Hall.
The negotiations were at an impasse largely because of the
negative attitude of Bruce Noren and his unfriendly Friend$ of
the Library. From the outset Noren tried to sabotage the
negotiations he was supported by Board chairman, Margaret Rayner,
wife of Ironwood School Superintendent, James Rayner.
Hat Changing, also known as Musical Hats
One can only wonder what Noren had in his
head when trying his utmost to kill the deal. Throughout last
week's meeting he and his Friend$ of the Library kept changing
their hats. One moment they were wearing their library board
hats, then the next moment their wearing their "Friend$" hat. In
fact once or twice Noren wore his "Mayor's Hat" and once even
tried on his majesty's Imperial Crown. In the end, he sat there
on the losing end of a 4-2 vote, appropriately wearing of all
things his dunce cap.
Noren had done everything he could to stop the deal he even
tried cutting off debate when he had no authority to do so. He
told this writer he was out of order, when in fact he, Noren was
out of order, as he was not in charge of the meeting. He even
allowed the librarian who has no authority whatsoever, to open
the floor to the unfriendly Friend$ of the Library. The
librarian is a guest at the board meeting not a member.
Overthrow the Township Board!
Gemma Lamb the secretary/treasurer of the
FRIEND$$$$$, took off her councilman hat and proposed over and
over again that the FRIEND$ should become Unfriendly to the
Township and take over their board just as they did in the city
in last November's elections.
Another not so friendly friend introduced herself as Bernie
DeHutt. MS. DeHutt used the words "ugly" and "frightening" over
and over again to describe her feelings about the issue. She
never did explain why she felt that the Township was obligated
to turn their revenues over to the Ironwood Library. She, along
with tax and spend Councilman Suzy Toth seem unable to grasp the
notion that the Township is subsidizing the City not the other
way around!
DeHutt also echoed the sentiments of Lamb, Rayner and Noren that
they should find candidates to overthrow the township board.
Nothing like tampering in other people's affairs.
Mrs. Rayner told this writer that membership at the library had
grown and that the township withdrawal would not hurt the
library operation. But, this proved not to be the case. The
librarian Elaine Erickson (wife of City Manager Scot Erickson)
told the board that, if the Township moved their revenues to
Bessemer the Library would have to reduce hours from the current
52 to just 36 hours and layoff personnel. So Suzy and Bernie
here's the scenario, Township gives money to city. City then can
have extra library benefits. Library can be open 52 hours not 36
hours. Township gives money to Bessemer. Bessemer gets extra
benefits and longer hours. Ironwood must curtail services and
hours.
OK Suzy, now, who's subsidizing who?
Noren had produced estimates for the library board all intended
to steer the board towards a stalemate and an ultimate "no"
vote. His numbers were contrived to always lead to one
conclusion.
In the words of Andrew Lang "He uses statistics as a drunken man
uses lamp-posts... for support rather than illumination."
Fortunately, the members of the library board decided that a no
vote would get them nowhere, and in fact, it would be a step
backwards to turn down the Township offer. So, with good the
judgment shown by Mrs. Andresen and the other three level headed
members of the library board, the contract proposal passed 4-2.
Tonight, again sensible minds at the Township prevailed and the
contract was approved. Both the City and the Township will be
the beneficiaries of the new contract. It was a good conclusion
for all concerned.
As for Noren, he remains as Winston Churchill
once described "A modest little person, with much to be modest
about."
|